Showing posts with label Alexis Wolfe. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Alexis Wolfe. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Think politics and religion are divisive? Try Gardasil!

Share
OK, gotta admit I laughed quite hard over the whole Michele Bachmann debacle with Gardasil. I’m no unconditional fan of Gardasil, the controversial HPV vaccine, but Bachmann’s remarks about Gardasil causing mental retardation were simply over the top. It’s possible that she was referring to Alexis Wolf, a teenager whose parents believe that she suffered brain damage as a result of Gardasil-induced seizures, but who knows? Ms. Bachmann is keeping mum.

Still, the bigger issue is substantially more depressing. It’s that the subject of vaccination in general, and Gardasil in particular, is so divisive.

I’ve read multiple blogs where scientists do a knee-jerk ridicule number on anyone who questions Gardasil, and then go on to deride anything but mainstream medicine. I’ve read multiple blogs where anti-vaxxers do a knee-jerk ridicule number on anyone who supports Gardasil, and attribute nothing but mercenary motivation to the medical industry in general.

My God, that’s depressing. And worse, unproductive.

Vaccinations are a miracle. Ask anyone who has suffered polio. But are they are a perfect miracle? Nope. Not by a long shot (pun intended. Sorry about that).

My hope is that both scientists and thoughtful consumers will eventually recognize a basic fact: some vaccines are pretty damn great, but that doesn’t mean that scientists and consumers alike should roll over and stop asking serious questions about them. And it doesn’t mean that you’re an anti-science idiot if you just say no sometimes.

Human physiology is an infinitely complex thing, and we’re a long way from fully understanding it. We know vaccines can do proven damage in a tiny minority of cases. We should be working to understand why, and how we can eliminate that risk too.

We should be looking for the unintended consequences that come with many well-intentioned interventions and eliminating them. And we should be asking questions about a possible cascade effect—perhaps you don’t drop dead on the spot. But could components of multiple vaccines build up over the years, and/or intensify other environmental triggers in the system? Can we identify those people who could be particularly vulnerable to autoimmune disease triggers, and come up with a strategy for them?

Can we be honest about the risks of disease, the risks that lead to disease (e.g. smoking and lousy diet contributing to persistent HPV infection) and the small risks of vaccination? For God’s sake, can we all act, and react, like grown-ups?

The best exchange I ever had with a GYN was with one who at first was very skeptical about the idea that eating your vegetables can reduce the incidence of persistent HPV infection by some 50 percent. I gave her a link to a study. And instead of going very silent, or finding some nit-picky thing to focus on, or rolling her eyes, “Thank you,” she said. “This looks extremely interesting. I’ll read it carefully and see if I should talk to my patients about it. I had no idea.”

Now THAT’S a person who can hear both sides of the conversation. And so I could hear her, too, when she said, “But you should stand in my shoes for a day to understand why I support Gardasil.”

Hey, can we talk?

Friday, April 16, 2010

Gardasil and seizures to be considered by Vaccine Court

Share
Last year the FDA mandated a revised label for Gardasil, warning health care providers about the continuing reports of syncope in those who’ve received the HPV vaccine, including “jerking movements, loss of bladder control, and other signs that resemble epileptic seizures, but is not epilepsy.”

However, stories about post- Gardasil epilepsy, continuing seizures and convulsions that are certainly not merely “syncope” continue to pour in—and on Wednesday the Ronan Law Firm filed a petition “in the United States Court of Federal Claims seeking damages for injuries suffered by 16 year old Alexis Wolf after she received the human papillomavirus vaccine, Gardasil. The case seeks recovery under the terms of the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program.”

Wolf, who is diabetic, received all three Gardasil shots although she had already begun exhibiting some perplexing behavioral issues by the time she got the third shot. Eventually a psychiatrist realized that she was in fact suffering seizures that apparently cannot be controlled by medication. According to information posted by her parents, the former honor roll student now tests at a fourth grade level and is in constant pain.

Yesterday I posed a question about Merck's HPV vaccine Gardasil, seizures and mitochondrial disease here .

It will be interesting to see how the federal vaccine court, which in 2008 awarded damages to a child whose undiagnosed mitochondrial disease was aggravated by multiple vaccines, rules on this new case.

Meanwhile, best wishes to Ms. Wolf and her family.

© 2010 http://www.gardasilhpv.com/.Permission is freely given to reproduce the first two paragraphs of this article, along with a link back to this site and the entirety of the article. For other uses, please contact Kristin at gardasilhpv@gmail.com.